Eagles Fantasy Football: Why You Should Target Jeremy Maclin over DeSean Jackson

Jasen Shen@jaysizzlesCorrespondent IJuly 9, 2012

Welcome to the J Series

As your fantasy football draft nears, you’ll have to ready yourself into making some difficult decisions.  However, you won’t have to make them alone.

This is where two featured columnists—Jasen Shen and Jason Fraychineaud— will use the maximum of 350 words in an attempt to put a heated fantasy football debate to rest.

Over the course of training camp and beyond, we will be looking at some of the closest battles and make argument for who warrants your team’s selection.

On tap today: DeSean Jackson versus Jeremy Maclin.

It might be DeSean Jackson who sits atop the Philadelphia Eagles’ depth chart, but let’s not lose sight of who the Philadelphia Eagles’ No.1 wide receiver truly is.

After battling a mysterious illness that forced him out of last year’s training camp, Jeremy Maclin enters his fourth year as a primary breakout candidate for 2012.  While Maclin has already proven that he comes equipped with a skill set featuring great route running, reliable hands and breakaway speed, it hasn’t stopped him from adding on a considerable amount of muscle during the offseason.  This new physique will not only make Maclin more physically imposing against smaller defenders, but should also lead to more red-zone targets as well.

In contrast, Jackson’s fantasy value is heavily reliant on his speed and big-play ability—things that can be neutralized with deeper coverage and a shortened field.   His drop off in production indicates that opposing defenses have already begun figuring out an effective game plan that limits his home-run threat.


Ironically enough, it is D-Jax’s greatest attribute that makes his counterpart the safer fantasy selection.  With Jackson’s daunting speed consuming defenses and forcing them to shift their alignments, Maclin will routinely benefit from single coverage. 

Jackson only missed one game due to suspension in 2011, while Maclin missed three due to injury.  However, even with the extra playing time, quarterback Michael Vick only targeted the speedy wideout seven more times.

In fact, Maclin recorded five more receptions, four more first downs and one more touchdown, while averaging more receiving yards per game.

Although each of Jackson’s receptions netted an average of three more yards, according to Pro Football Focus, he also dropped nine of 67 catchable passes thrown his way in 2011 and 12 of 61 during the previous year.  For a wide receiver who only averages 57 catches per season, his 16.4 percent drop rate is downright offensive when you consider how many fantasy points he is leaving on the board.

Now I don’t want to leave you with a bad impression of the electrifying receiver, but can you handle this kind of stress?


You can read the case for Jackson here.


Follow me on Twitter @JasenShen