Winning by a scoreline of 7-6 (6), 7-5, the match seemed far from a straight-set encounter, especially for going in the Serb's favor.
Novak performed similarly against Federer as he did in his semifinals win over Juan Martin del Potro. In this sense, he went down early in the opening set and looked sluggish while attempting to get the service break back.
He kept the balls in play and waited for Roger's errors, and sure enough they came. Feds was up 3-0 in the first set and 5-3 (40-15) in the second, only to lose both of them by a matter of points.
The first set could have gone either way as Roger was able to scrape himself back into the match, fighting off two set points until he would collapse at six points a piece in the tiebreak, but the second set was supposed to allow for a third.
Looking back at the entire tournament it seems simple to think that Federer and Djokovic would likely square off in the final and display a classic. David Ferrer, Jo-Wilfried Tsonga, Tomas Berdych and Janko Tipsarevic probably wouldn't have taken out Nole in the semis or the final.
The other contender besides Murray would be Juan Martin del Potro, and of course, these four made the semifinals.
Delpo couldn't keep up the firepower to move Djokovic around the court and Murray couldn't keep his head together after surrendering the first set. These were all ideas that the tennis world had seen before.
Would Federer play well in the final and get off to a quick start only to find his opponent clawing back in the match? Would Djokovic use his stubborn defense and aggressive ability to pinpoint the Swiss' backhand in order to keep the match even?
Roger is a quick starter—he ordinarily either breaks in the first game of the opening set or drops that set and breaks in the first game of the second set, and this occurred in both sets.
But the Maestro seems to be a little out of sorts these days and has shown a lack of confidence in closing out sets (forget matches). His forehand isn't doing enough damage and his backhand is too erratic, but Novak was labeled as the favorite to win the tournament from the start, and this spectacle played out as if we had all read the script before experiencing the tournament.
Follow Bleacher Report Featured Columnist and Tennis Community Leader, Jeff Cohn, on Twitter.