Cardinals vs. Pirates: Score, Grades and Analysis for NLDS Game 4

Tim KeeneyContributor IOctober 7, 2013

With his team facing elimination from the NLDS, St. Louis Cardinals rookie Michael Wacha turned in an absolute gem on Monday afternoon at PNC Park to beat the Pittsburgh Pirates, 2-1, and even the series at two games apiece. 

The 22-year-old Wacha was perfect through five and gave up no hits through 7.1 innings before Pedro Alvarez eventually ended the youngster's bid at history with a late solo home run. 

Still, Wacha finished with a spectacular line: 7.1 innings, one hit, two walks, one earned run, nine strikeouts and the all-important "W" after a few more youngsters—Carlos Martinez and Trevor Rosenthal—were terrific in relief.   

ESPN Stats & Info shared this telling fact:

Yahoo! Sports' Jeff Passan talked about the significance of the Cards' youngsters' performances:

Pittsburgh starter Charlie Morton was able to keep pace with Wacha through five innings. But while he kept the Cardinals off the scoreboard, it was pretty clear early on that he wasn't nearly as sharp as the St. Louis youngster. 

Finally, in the sixth inning, one of his four walks came back to hurt him. After putting Carlos Beltran on first to start the inning, Morton served up a 2-2 pitch to Matt Holliday, who crushed it over the center-field fence to give the Cardinals the 2-0 lead:

Morton was removed shortly thereafter. He gave up three hits, four walks and two runs in 5.2 innings while striking out four. 

Two runs seemed like an insurmountable lead against Wacha, who looked unhittable for the second start in a row, but Pittsburgh would eventually rally in front of a fired-up crowd in Pittsburgh. 

After Wacha struck out Marlon Byrd to start the eighth, Alvarez crushed a 3-1 pitch to cut St. Louis' lead in half. ESPN Stats & Info noted the historical significance for the white-hot Alvarez:

Martinez came on in place of Wacha to get the Cards out of the eighth inning, though, and Rosenthal subsequently got MVP candidate Andrew McCutchen to pop out to end a nail-biting ninth inning and preserve the series-extending victory. 

As's Jenifer Langosch pointed out, the win was quite the exhibition of youth from the Cardinals with their backs against the wall:


Player Grades

Michael Wacha, Cardinals: A

PITTSBURGH, PA - OCTOBER 07:  Michael Wacha #52 of the St. Louis Cardinals throws a pitch against the Pittsburgh Pirates during Game Four of the National League Division Series at PNC Park on October 7, 2013 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.  (Photo by Justin
Justin K. Aller/Getty Images

Oh, so that's who Shakira was singing about and Fozzie Bear was talking about. It all makes sense now. 

Wacha may have lost his no-hitter, but remember: This is a 22-year-old who was making his first career postseason start, in an elimination game no less—and he struck out nine and gave up one measly hit over seven-plus innings.

Just let that sink in. 

After losing a no-hitter with two outs in the ninth inning in his very last start, Wacha has now allowed two hits and four walks while striking out 18 over his last 16.0 innings. 

Wacha Wacha, indeed. 


Charlie Morton, Pirates: B-

PITTSBURGH, PA - OCTOBER 07:  Charlie Morton #50 of the Pittsburgh Pirates walks back to the dugout after being pulled by manager Clint Hurdle #13 in the sixth inning against the St. Louis Cardinals during Game Four of the National League Division Series
Justin K. Aller/Getty Images

Morton admirably dueled with Wacha for a while, but his walk total and high pitch count eventually did him in. He ran out of gas in the fifth inning and gave up the game-deciding hit to Holliday.

Overall, it was a so-so performance. 

You have to give Morton credit for limiting a dangerous Cardinals lineup to just three hits, but he picked a terrible time to start losing command.

After giving up 1.6 free passes per start in his first 19 outings of the season, Morton has now walked nine in just 10.0 innings over his last two starts.

If the Pirates are able to advance to the NLCS, Morton needs to relocate his control.


Matt Holliday, Cardinals: A

PITTSBURGH, PA - OCTOBER 07:  Matt Holliday #7 of the St. Louis Cardinals celebrates in the dugout after scoring a two run home run against Charlie Morton #50 of the Pittsburgh Pirates in the sixth inning during Game Four of the National League Division S
Justin K. Aller/Getty Images

Coming into the game just 2-for-12 with one extra-base hit in the series, Holliday wasn't exactly earning himself many fans. 

With one swing of the bat, however, he ended the pitcher's duel, made sure Wacha's brilliant performance didn't go to waste and helped St. Louis extend its season. 


What's Next

The pivotal Game 5 from St. Louis will be on Wednesday at 5:07 p.m. ET. Adam Wainwright is scheduled to take the mound against rookie Gerrit Cole, who is replacing A.J. Burnett, per Karen Price at the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review

Watch postseason baseball live on or your mobile device.