NFL Madden 2009: Really Bad Madden Ratings for NFC Edition

Greg TrippiediCorrespondent IJune 28, 2008

Yesterday, I wrote about the underrated and overrated Madden ratings for AFC players. Today, I will be doing the same with the NFC.



Dallas Cowboys

Overrated:  Marc Columbo (88)

Underrated:  Chris Canty (84)


New York Giants

Overrated:  Eli Manning (93), Jeremy Shockey (95)

Underrated:  Gerris Wilkinson (77)


Philadelphia Eagles

Overrated:  Correll Buckhalter (82)

Underrated:  Lorenzo Booker (76)


Washington Redskins

Overrated:  London Fletcher (96)

Underrated:  Stephon Heyer (76)


Arizona Cardinals

Overrated:  Antrel Rolle (89)

Underrated:  Travis Laboy (75), Karlos Dansby (85)


St. Louis Rams

Overrated:  Randy McMichael (84)

Underrated:  Marc Bulger (89)


San Francisco 49ers

Overrated:  Walt Harris (88)

Underrated:  Brandon Moore (76)


Seattle Seahawks

Overrated:  Julian Peterson (95)

Underrated:  Sean Locklear (86)


Chicago Bears

Overrated:  WR Devin Hester (81)

Underrated:  Mark Anderson (84)


Detroit Lions

Overrated:  Shaun McDonald (87)

Underrated:  Kalvin Pearson (73)


Green Bay Packers

Overrated:  Nick Barnett (94)

Underrated:  Donald Lee (83)


Minnesota Vikings

Overrated:  Darren Sharper (92)

Underrated:  Brian Robison (82)


Atlanta Falcons

Overrated:  Matt Ryan (83)

Underrated:  Jerious Norwood (82)


Carolina Panthers

Overrated:  Ken Lucas (88)

Underrated:  DJ Hackett (86)


New Orleans Saints

Overrated:  Deuce McAllister (86)

Underrated:  Terrance Copper (73)


Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Overrated:  Jeff Garcia (90)

Underrated:  Sammy Davis (72)