New King In Newcastle, Again: Why Alan Pardew Will Be Bad for the Club

Matthew DonatoCorrespondent IDecember 11, 2010

Will we ever be this happy for an extended period of time?
Will we ever be this happy for an extended period of time?Mark Thompson/Getty Images

My favorite English club team, Newcastle United, recently fired manager Chris Hughton and replaced him with Alan Pardew, and it couldn't be worse for my psyche.

I found out about the sacking while compiling the Around the Block, Around the World segment we do on The Starting Gatea page we do early in the nightand it was all I could think about for the rest of the day.

Hughton had been a successful manager since coming in as a caretaker, leading the club into the middle of the Premiership after a dominant campaign in the League Championship. It's more than we could ask for after numerous seasons of transfer miscues, front office mistakes and and on-pitch failures.

His departure was never called for by the fans this season, and his performance had been written about in good light. If Chris Hughton could be fired in his first real managerial gig despite success and the backing of fans, what decent coach would ever want to take up the position, especially given the club's history of this type of behavior?

Since I started following Newcastle in 2006, the club has gone through many managers. In fact, they were going through a managerial change, Graeme Souness to Bobby Roeder, at the time I picked up the club. Since then I have watched Sam Allardyce, Joe Kinnear, Kevin Keegan and Alan Shearer try their hand as Newcastle manager before Hughton got his chance.

For thos of you keeping track at home, that is seven managers in under six seasons. Even the Yankees in their Steinbrenner/Billy Martin heyday and the wretched Detroit Lions cannot claim such a carousel of managers.

"By God, we will be unstoppable!"

Granted, some of these managers have been on an interim basis. Bobby Roeder was just a placeholder, as was Joe Kinnear, until something better came along.

But even managers that were chosen for the long-term have been unable to produce. Sam Allardyce was handpicked by owner Mike Ashley, but succeeded only in talking a big game while his squads failed to back it up on the pitch.

Kevin Keegan was the manager during Newcastle's last successful run in the early 90s, a stretch that saw the team climb out of what was then called Division 1 to finish second, sixth, second and second respectively in the Premiership from 1993 to 1996. He abruptly resigned after that run, only to return in 2008 to take over for Sam Allardyce.

I was watching a live broadcast of Newcastle's game against Manchester United (I even kept a live blog of the game) when it was announced that Keegan would return as manager, and I remember the elation and expectations that came with the return of King Kevin.

I was the fella on the left, and I think I imagined the two on the right

Unfortunately, he lasted less than a year after disagreements with owner Mike Ashley and Director Dennis Wise over transfers. The aftermath of these quarrels turned fans against the owner and Keegan from the club.

Nine months later. Not our proudest moment.

Alan Shearer's tenure was nothing more than a huge tease to the fans. Shearer was the face of the franchise as a goal scorer until his retirement in 2006. He then came in as manager to save a sinking ship that was doomed to relegation, and almost succeeded.

Fans thought he was the savior needed to steer the team back to the Premiership, instead it was just like the old days.

In our heads we thought, "Well, management ran Keegan out of town and sold our best young player for pennies on the dollar, but so long as Shearer is at the helm I will stand by this team forever".

"You'll never turn on me again, right, Mauley McBear?"

But in another staggeringly brilliant public relations move, Shearer was cut down, held in limbo over the job throughout the offseason, and finally not re-fired.

When Newcastle failed to lure Keegan back, the job went to Chris Hughton as a caretaker until they could find their long-term manager. We looked dead in the water, and doomed to mire in the second tier of English football.

And then something wonderful happened.

Hughton did an immaculate job as manager during the club's year in the League Championship. Newcastle dominated the league over the course of the season and stormed their way back into the Premiership. We were contenders again, and I felt a sense of pride in the team that I had not felt since the initial honeymoon of choosing to root for them in the first place.

The current year has brought mixed success, but has still been better than many fans had predicted. The fact that there have been any positives has more than made up for the negatives, and following the team has never been more fun.

We were shut out by Manchester United in the opener, but came right back with a 6-0 win over Aston Villa in the next match. We kicked powerhouse Chelsea out of the Carling Cup only to lose to Arsenal in the next round.

Andy Carrol has emerged from our youth team as a constant scoring threat, but talented Joey Barton cannot stay out of trouble with officials both on and off the field. We upended rival Sunderland with a five-goal barrage and crept past Arsenal after losing in league matches, only to find ourselves winless in our last four contests.


It's been that kind of season, except the manager was thrown off on the corkscrew.

Despite his recent success, it would seem that those last four games have been the deciding factor for Chris Hughton's future at Newcastle.

Wait, what?

Mike Ashley, who took over ownership of the club soon after I began following them, showed once again why he has been about as popular with fans as an acid and salt rinse after a root canal. According to Ashley, the team needs to be managed by someone with more experience.

On paper it's a justifiable move, something along the lines of "if the team is doing this well with some nobody as manager, think of how well they'd do with an accomplished manager." It would be like the New Orleans Hornetswho are exceeding all expectations by starting the season 11-1 with rookie head coach Monty Williamsfiring Williams because of their current 2-5 skid and  replacing him with perennial also-ran Don Nelson.

The only problem here is that whoever the soccer version of Don Nelson is was not available, so instead they hired a journeyman Pardew, or the P.J. Carlesimo of soccer coaches. 

Will Joey Barton be the Latrell Sprewell of soccer?

Can Newcastle definitely say they are in a better position than they were before firing Hughton? No. At best, they can say they broke even on this move.

In reality, they have burned the bridges of every personnel member the team could ever want to sign in the future. Who will sign with a club that will unceremoniously fire you even if you overperform? Why even risk it?

Pardew told the BBC that other managers had sent him text messages saying that "he must be mad to sign there," and I am inclined to agree with them. Even with his five-and-a-half-year deal, how long does he expect to stay with a club who fired their last manager after he exceeded any and all expectations? With Newcastle's managerial history, how did the club even generate any interest in the position from career-oriented managers?

The move may not affect the team this season, but it certainly will in the long run, and not for the better. And to think I let them get my hopes up.


    World Cup Tactics Explained: Belgium’s 3-4-2-1

    World Football logo
    World Football

    World Cup Tactics Explained: Belgium’s 3-4-2-1

    Tifo Football
    via Tifo Football

    Southgate Keen to Unleash His Bold New England

    World Football logo
    World Football

    Southgate Keen to Unleash His Bold New England

    via Goal

    Newcastle United will benefit from difficult start to the season

    Newcastle United logo
    Newcastle United

    Newcastle United will benefit from difficult start to the season

    Newcastle Toons
    via Newcastle Toons

    Russia vs. Egypt: Make or Break for Salah's Pharaohs

    World Football logo
    World Football

    Russia vs. Egypt: Make or Break for Salah's Pharaohs

    Gill Clark
    via Bleacher Report